Another "new" Tolkien book

Seeking knowledge in, of, and about Middle-earth.
Post Reply
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

My review is now up at The Journal of Tolkien Research, complete with a special guest appearance by our very own Eldy!

The Fall of Númenor (2022) by J.R.R. Tolkien, edited by Brian Sibley
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
Jude
Lán de Grás
Posts: 8610
Joined: Sat Jan 21, 2006 4:54 pm

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Jude »

Thanks for that - that's the information on the book I was looking for!
Image
User avatar
Eldy
Drowning in Anadûnê
Posts: 1523
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2013 3:44 am
Location: Maryland, United States
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Eldy »

It's good to read your thoughts in full, Voronwë! I'm kinda glad I only flipped through the book; the chapter for II.3175 sounds like it would have had me breaking out in hives. :P Which is a shame, because the alternate take on Míriel, Pharazôn, and Elentir from "The History of the Akallabêth" is genuinely interesting stuff, just ... not presented like this. :neutral:
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

To be fair, that probably was the worst example of contradictory material placed together with no real explanation. And all he needed to do was add something like "one tale holds that ___________" and then "but in the Akallabêth it is said that _____________." Oh well. I still think that the book has value, and as you said earlier in the thread, if it gets some more casual fans interested in the Second Age tales, all the better.
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
Eldy
Drowning in Anadûnê
Posts: 1523
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2013 3:44 am
Location: Maryland, United States
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Eldy »

Yeah, there are a number of pretty minor changes to Sibley's method of presenting the texts that I think would've left me feeling much more positive about the book. Like you say, oh well. :P And if this does in fact give poor Elentir his moment in the sun with casual readers, that's at least one thing to be grateful for. :D
User avatar
Inanna
Meetu's little sister
Posts: 17885
Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2006 5:03 pm

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Inanna »

Voronwë the Faithful wrote:My review is now up at The Journal of Tolkien Research, complete with a special guest appearance by our very own Eldy!

The Fall of Númenor (2022) by J.R.R. Tolkien, edited by Brian Sibley
Interesting. For me, the passages quoted from Letters etc. were insightful.

I did cringe at Sibley’s denigration as a scholar….
'You just said "your getting shorter": you've obviously been drinking too much ent-draught and not enough Prim's.' - Jude
User avatar
Alatar
of Vinyamar
Posts: 10778
Joined: Thu Dec 01, 2005 11:39 pm
Location: Ireland
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Alatar »

What exactly makes one a scholar? Lets not get overly sniffy and gatekeeping. I hate snobbery,.
Image
The Vinyamars on Stage! This time at Bag End
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

Inanna wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 2:02 pm I did cringe at Sibley’s denigration as a scholar….
I certainly was not meaning to denigrate him. I'm sorry it made you cringe.
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

Alatar wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 3:39 pm What exactly makes one a scholar? Lets not get overly sniffy and gatekeeping. I hate snobbery,.
A scholar is someone who does scholarly work. I wouldn't call someone who does not do engineering work an engineer either. That's not snobbery. It's fact.
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
Eldy
Drowning in Anadûnê
Posts: 1523
Joined: Sat Sep 14, 2013 3:44 am
Location: Maryland, United States
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Eldy »

The "About this Book" introduction to The Fall of Númenor, which can be read in the Google Books preview, contrasts Sibley's approach of "provid[ing] extracts ... with as few editorial interventions as possible" with Christopher's "peerless, insightful commentary and analysis" that accompanied "the definitive presentation" of his father's works. I don't think it's unreasonable or insulting to note that one of these approaches is a scholarly endeavor and one is not. After all, the main selling point of The Fall of Númenor, even more than the 2010s editions of the Great Tales, is that it's more accessible to casual readers than UT or especially HoMe, partly because it is less wonkish (i.e., scholarly) in tone. To that end, it makes sense that the chosen editor is someone whose background is principally in creating adaptations (and companions to adaptations) of Tolkien's works rather than academic studies. That doesn't mean one is inherently better or worse than the other, though arguably FoN would've been more interesting if Sibley had shown more of his creative chops and produced something closer to the 1977 Silmarillion, which is—by design—even less "scholarly." But that likely would have been impossible to produce quickly enough to serve as an unofficial ROP tie-in.
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

Yes. Exactly.
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

A more positive (but less detailed) review in Amon Hen:
Attachments
Amon Hen 298 13.jpg
Amon Hen 298 13.jpg (507.17 KiB) Viewed 8046 times
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
narya
chocolate bearer
Posts: 4939
Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2005 7:27 am
Location: Wishing I could be beachcombing, or hiking, or dragon boating
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by narya »

Voronwë the Faithful wrote: Sat Dec 24, 2022 5:34 pm
A scholar is someone who does scholarly work. I wouldn't call someone who does not do engineering work an engineer either. That's not snobbery. It's fact.
I disagree. But I don't feel comfortable saying more.
In the midst of winter, I found there was, within me, an invincible summer. ~ Albert Camus
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

Please do, narya. I promise I won't get offended.
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
Inanna
Meetu's little sister
Posts: 17885
Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2006 5:03 pm

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Inanna »

I’ve been waffling over posting here again. My issue was not with calling the work “non-scholarly”, my issue was with calling the author “not a scholar”. Works can be criticized without criticizing the person. And anyway, if the book is not meant to be scholarly (as Eldy pointed out), then pointing out whether the author is not a scholar feels…. well, as I said, I cringed.
'You just said "your getting shorter": you've obviously been drinking too much ent-draught and not enough Prim's.' - Jude
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

That's fair, however there are a couple of points that I would like to make. First of all, while I agree that the book probably is not really directed as much at Tolkien scholars as it is towards more casual fans, it is not billed in that way, and Sibley is described as a "Tolkien expert" which certainly could suggest that he is an accomplished Tolkien scholar. Secondly, this review is not directed at the general public, it is a review for The Journal of Tolkien Research, a periodical specifically for Tolkien scholars. Thirdly, contrary to what you claim, I never said that Sibley was "not a scholar." What I said, exactly, is that "he has little history of Tolkien scholarship." Which is a simple fact, and certainly relevant in a journal dedicated to Tolkien scholarship and in comparing the book to previous similar books edited by Christopher, Carl Hostetter, John Rateliff, and others, which are much more scholarly works, and in my opinion, much more successful ones, as well. I understand that you, Al, narya, and probably others here disagree with me. That is fine. Different opinions respectively expressed is what this site is all about.
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
narya
chocolate bearer
Posts: 4939
Joined: Sat Dec 03, 2005 7:27 am
Location: Wishing I could be beachcombing, or hiking, or dragon boating
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by narya »

I was concerned with your saying that someone who is not doing engineering is not an engineer. I disagree.

I have been an engineer all my life. Being an engineer is much more than just a job. I'm not doing engineering at the moment, but I will always be an engineer. It is my identity. It is how I view and interact with the world.

As for who is a scholar, that depends on your definition. Webster sets the bar pretty low, and I have passed all four definitions at one time or another.

1. a person who attends a school or studies under a teacher - a pupil
2.a. a person who has done advanced study in a special field
2.b. a learned person
3. a holder of a scholarship

Others define a scholar as someone working in academia, someone who is published, or someone who is recognized as contributing new knowledge to a field. I haven't worked in academia in decades, but I have contributed to two books, and I was a subject matter expert in a newly evolving field. But I never called myself a scholar. If someone else wants to identify themselves a scholar, by whatever definition, I'm not going to quibble.
In the midst of winter, I found there was, within me, an invincible summer. ~ Albert Camus
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

You earned the right to be called an engineer. Someone who has never put the study and work to become an engineer can call themselves an engineer, but it would not have the same validity that your claim has even if they were "working as an engineer" and you currently are not. My choice of words may been been inexact but I don't think that we are truly in disagreement.
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
User avatar
Inanna
Meetu's little sister
Posts: 17885
Joined: Sat Jan 07, 2006 5:03 pm

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Inanna »

V, you exactly said “Sibley simply is not a scholar” in the last page. Although now that I reread it that phrase sounds like an excuse for why he has not provided detailed endnotes. Taken together with the beginning of the review when his lack of Tolkien authorship is elaborated, it felt denigrating.

'You just said "your getting shorter": you've obviously been drinking too much ent-draught and not enough Prim's.' - Jude
User avatar
Voronwë the Faithful
At the intersection of here and now
Posts: 47800
Joined: Mon Nov 21, 2005 1:41 am
Contact:

Re: Another "new" Tolkien book

Post by Voronwë the Faithful »

I thought you were referring to what I wrote in the review.

I promise I won't share or comment on any future reviews or papers that I might have published here.
"Spirits in the shape of hawks and eagles flew ever to and from his halls; and their eyes could see to the depths of the seas, and pierce the hidden caverns beneath the world."
Post Reply